This Christian Life

SEARCH


STATISTICS: 433 entries, 757 comments
LAST UPDATE: 01.17.08 11:13am

BROWSE BY CATEGORY

Christianity Meets Culture (46)
Church (62)
Culture (16)
Guest Bloggers (3)
Mission Trips (16)
Money (2)
Music, Poetry, & Scripture (73)
My Life (74)
News (51)
Observations (25)
Postmodernism (31)
Recommendation (46)
Site Related (12)
Social Justice (11)
Spirituality (21)

>> List All Posts by Category

ARCHIVES BY DATE

September 2007
June 2007
April 2007
March 2007
January 2007
November 2006

ADDITIONAL PERSPECTIVES

Internet Monk
I was thinking...
Martin Roth Online
Thinking Out Loud
Aaron B Smith
Next Wave
Beautiful Feet
e~mergent kiwi
Matt Gough

ORGANIZATIONS I LIKE

Mosaic
Mosaic Life
Mars Hill
That the World May Know
Compass Arts
Gospelcom.net
Crossroads Ministry
National Alliance to End Homelessness

PEOPLE I LIKE

Charlie Peacock
Brian McLaren
David Roche
McNair Wilson
Leonard Sweet
Brennan Manning
Garison Keeler

View My Portfolio

Follow the Rabbi

Listed on Blogwise

March 24, 2005

Leaders call ‘Emerging Church Movement’ a threat to Gospel

Category: Postmodernism

From an article on bpnews.net:

A recently developed way of envisioning church known as the “Emerging Church Movement” deals carelessly with Scripture and compromises the Gospel, according to a prominent evangelical scholar and a Southern Baptist seminary president.

But Brian McLaren, one of the movement’s leaders, told Baptist Press that such criticisms are unfounded and that the Emerging Church Movement is “seeking to be more faithful to Christ” in the current postmodern cultural context.

Threat, shhhhmet. I think if there’s any threat that should be discussed in the church square, it is the threat to Christendom, as claimed by the authors of “The Shaping of Things to Come,” by Alan Hirsch and Michael Frost. They readily point out that the “institutional church” is quickly losing ground in today’s “postmodern” culture. The church kingdom (aka Christendom) that Constantine set into motion is based on an attractional method of ministry. In other words, if you build it, they should come. However, a missional, incarnational method (i.e.: going to where people live and reaching them there) of reaching people and doing church is more appropriate for today and happens to be more akin to Jesus style of ministry.

This should not be taken lightly. The problem is, we’ve been ignoring the incarnational concept for so long, few of us have a vision for it, much less does the word even show up in our proverbial dictionaries. Looking at the early church one would quickly realize the incarnational, missional model and the validity of it.

Let’s stop arguing about how church should be done and just get out there and start loving.

Posted by pablohart on March 24, 2005 09:09 AM
Comments

The Emerging Church movement deals carelessly with Scripture? Oh, come on. I've sat through enough hermeneutics classes on textual criticism, and redaction criticism. All these so-called methods are no less careless towards Scripture than the newer methods of narrative criticism (which is used a lot in post-modern contexts) and the like. I don't see how trying to determine the exact words of a text is more holy and honoring than trying to determine the meaning of those words in a complete thought.

Posted by Jamison at March 24, 2005 9:57 AM

I've seen too much 'denomination preservation' in my own life to know that truth can exist, albeit stifled, in somethiing locked in to its own set of ways.
The "emerging church" is emerging because it is REAL, it speaks love without doctrine, hope without practices, and life without a statement of beliefs.
The protestent church fought the catholic church in part because they had become institutionalized. How sad is it that the same has happened to the protestant church?
I believe, with all my heart, that much good exists in the church today........and will continue to support what they do......but when they fight back at those who challenge the "status quo" and say "let's be real," aren't they Missing the Point (McLaren fan here)?
Sorry to ramble, but just some random thoughts that were sparked by reading this.

Posted by Lynell at March 24, 2005 12:06 PM

Your title and opening quote remind me of an article I read a while ago. It is an article by one of my favorite authors, Wendell Berry. An excerpt can be found online:

http://www.resurgence.org/resurgence/issues/berry198.htm

I think your final comment will find synthesis with Mr. Berry.

Posted by Rob Walcott at March 24, 2005 8:09 PM

Add your comment


Name:

Email:

URL:

When posting please stay on topic. Posts may be removed if content isn't approved.

Ads shown below don't necessarily reflect my beliefs.

 

Archives | My testimony |
Powered by
Movable Type 3.2

RSS 1.0 | RSS 2.0 | Creative Commons | My ebay | Wish list | Portfolio | Photos

Center of the earth